“The distinction between the past, present and future is only a stubbornly persistent illusion” ― Albert Einstein

Universe: A Dream reigning in the veins

Showing posts with label History of Science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label History of Science. Show all posts

Saturday, 23 March 2024

Emmy Noether: Probably the best female Mathematician in the history




Consider that you are launching a ball into the air. The skill of juggling involves a dance between motion and rest, with the ball's speed decreasing as it rises and increasing as it descends. One of the fundamental ideas of physics is revealed in this dance: conservation laws. Earth, or juggling for that matter, is not the only place where conservation principles apply. These are general laws of physics that hold true in many branches of the subject. However, they aren't always clear-cut. Here's where the woman from Germany enters the scene. Her discovery revealed an incredibly straightforward relationship between these conservation rules and the symmetries of the world.

Emmy Noether, the woman who developed one of the most beautiful theorems in physics. Today (March 23) is her birthday.

Emmy Noether was a German mathematician who made significant contributions to abstract algebra and theoretical physics. She was born on March 23, 1882, in Erlangen, Germany, and died on April 14, 1935, in Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania, United States.

She developed what is now known as Noether's theorem, which is fundamental in the study of symmetries in physics. This theorem relates symmetries and conservation laws, showing that for every continuous symmetry in a physical system, there is a corresponding conserved quantity.

Despite facing discrimination as a woman in academia during her time, Noether made significant contributions to mathematics and physics. She worked at the University of Göttingen, where she collaborated with prominent mathematicians and physicists such as David Hilbert and Albert Einstein. Her work laid the foundation for modern algebra and had a profound impact on theoretical physics, particularly in the development of quantum mechanics and general relativity.

Noether thought about the issue raised by Hilbert and Einstein, namely that the General Relativity Theory appeared to violate the law of conservation of energy. This led to the development of her well-known theorem, which fundamentally altered the path of physics.

It's likely true that Emmy Noether is the best female mathematician in history. Noether's theorem fundamentally changed our view of the cosmos. Her pioneering work in abstract algebra also revolutionized mathematics.


Contributions

Emmy Noether made several significant contributions to mathematics and theoretical physics during her career. Some of her most notable contributions include:

1. Noether's Theorem: This is arguably her most famous contribution. Noether's theorem states that for every continuous symmetry in a physical system, there is a corresponding conserved quantity. This theorem has profound implications in theoretical physics, particularly in the conservation laws of energy, momentum, and angular momentum.

2.  Abstract Algebra: Noether made significant contributions to abstract algebra, particularly in the development of ring theory and group theory. She introduced the concept of "ideals" in ring theory, which has become a fundamental concept in modern algebra. Her work provided important insights into the structure of algebraic systems.

3. Invariant Theory: Noether worked on invariant theory, a branch of mathematics concerned with properties that remain unchanged under a group of transformations. Her work in this area helped to clarify and extend the understanding of the relationships between symmetry and invariance.

4.  Algebraic Geometry: Noether made contributions to algebraic geometry, particularly in the study of algebraic curves and surfaces. She developed the theory of "Noetherian rings" and made significant advances in understanding the properties of algebraic varieties.

5.  Physics: While primarily a mathematician, Noether's work had a profound impact on theoretical physics. Her theorem has applications in various areas of physics, including classical mechanics, quantum mechanics, and general relativity. She collaborated with notable physicists such as Albert Einstein and David Hilbert, contributing to the development of their theories.

6.  Teaching and Mentorship: Noether was also known for her exceptional teaching skills and mentorship of students. Despite facing discrimination as a woman in academia, she mentored several prominent mathematicians and physicists, inspiring future generations of researchers.

Emmy Noether's contributions to mathematics and theoretical physics have had a lasting impact on these fields, and she is widely regarded as one of the most influential mathematicians of the 20th century. She has left a lasting legacy, with her work continuing to influence research in various fields of science and mathematics.


Prabir Rudra

Share:

Saturday, 27 August 2022

Mathematical Theory of Probability: A historical perspective from Pascal to Laplace

 

                                     3 dice rolling problem

Terminology

The term 'Probability' literally means chance or odds or expectation or likelihood. The term originates from the medieval Latin word 'probabilis' meaning plausible. Probability is always utilized to study the behavior of stochastic (random) processes like tossing a coin or rolling a dice. Historically probability has always been closely associated with the term chance and used synonymously with it until we had a proper mathematical perspective in the 18th century. The early form of the theory was called the 'Doctrine of Chances'.

Origin

Probability finds its place in the ancient and medieval laws of evidence where they had to deal with proofs, credibility, and uncertainties of evidence in a court. Games of chance are believed to have existed as early as the Egyptian civilization. In the excavations of different tombs of the Pharaohs, they found a game called 'Hounds and Jackals' which matches closely with our modern-day game of 'Snakes and Ladders.' This must have been the early stage of the creation of dice. Throwing around a set of dice and betting on its outcome has been an ancient habit of humans and this has been passed on from one civilization to another. The first dice game found in the literature of the Christian era was known as 'Hazard', played with 2-3 dice. The game was thought to have been brought to Europe by the knights returning from the crusades. The pottery of the Greek civilization showed the existence of some games which involved various degrees of uncertainty. Present-day casinos all other the world have successfully carried on the legend to modern times. 



During Renaissance, Europe was a center of gambling and other games of chance which involved a humongous amount of wealth put at stake. Maritime insurance plans were supposed to be estimated based on the risks involved. But during that time (17th century) there was no proper mathematical framework that could provide a logical basis to calculate or predict the degree of risks involved in these. People would always like to know an estimate of returns for the wealth they put at stake. These could only be provided by a sound mathematical theory that could take into account the randomness (unpredictability) of the systems and thoroughly perform a risk analysis. Under such situations, the stage was set for the mathematicians of that era to step forward and start developing a mathematical framework that would fulfill the needs of the prevailing society.





The early form of the theory

The early form of the mathematical theory of probability can be attributed to four mathematicians of that era, namely, the Italian polymath Gerolamo Cardano, the French mathematicians Pierre de Fermat and Blaise Pascal, and the Dutch mathematician Christiaan Huygens. Cardano began his investigations as early as 1560, but his work was unknown to society for 100 years. He basically put his thoughts into investigating the sum of the numbers obtained from the throws of three dice. The randomness involved amazed him and he tried to find a pattern in it. This was such a booming topic in those days that Galileo could not stay away from it. In the early 17th century he considered the problem of throwing 3 dice and declared that it is possible to throw some numbers more often than others because there are more ways to create that number.  From the middle of the 17th century, there began a correspondence between Fermat and Pascal aiming to find a solution for the games of chance. This triggered a serious attempt towards the development of a mathematical basis of probability. In 1657 Huygens gave a comprehensive treatment to the concept. 

Subsequent developments

In the 18th century, the subject was taken up by the Swiss mathematician Jacob Bernoulli and the French mathematician Abraham De Moivre. In his Arcs Conjectandi (1713), Bernoulli derived the first version of the Law of Large Numbers (LLN), which states that the average of the results obtained from a large number of trials of a random experiment should be close to the expected value and the gap gradually decreases as the number of trails are increased. De Moivre in his Doctrine of Chances (1718) showed the method of calculating a wide range of complex probabilities.

By the 19th century, it was almost evident that the mathematical theory of probability is a powerful mathematical tool having a wide range of real-life applications. The randomness or uncertainties in various activities of human life and natural phenomenon can be well addressed by a well-formulated theory of probability. To re-affirm this idea German mathematician and physicist Gauss used the theory in astronomical studies and the predictions were great. From a few observational data, he determined the orbit of Ceres (a dwarf planet in the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter). He used the method of least squares to perform an error analysis to correct the errors in the observations, which became a routine analysis in astronomy thereafter. To do this he used the normal distribution of errors in his calculations, which is a probabilistic tool. In 1812 French scholar and polymath Laplace further developed the theory by introducing fundamental concepts of mathematical expectations which include the moment generating function, the method of least squares, and the testing of hypothesis. From here the mathematical theory of probability took a turn and slowly started to develop a bonding with the mathematical theory of statistics. It was understood that the two concepts are related and one cannot do without the other. 

                                       Dwarf planet Ceres

Probability in Physics

By the end of the 19th century, physics was gaining ground and was the leading science of the era. Classical mechanics developed by Newton, Lagrange, Hamilton, etc were no longer valid for the sub-atomic worlds. Science needed new physical theories to describe the observations. Who knew that the mathematical theory of probability will form the cornerstone of the new theories to come? It was found that the properties of gases like the temperature could only be expressed in terms of the motions of a large number of particles. This could not be done without the help of statistics as the number of particles that we are talking about here is huge. Ludwig Boltzmann and J. Willard Gibbs developed the field of Statistical Mechanics to address the problem, which involved the concepts of probabilities and statistics. 

                                    Gas particles


The laws followed by the sub-atomic (micro) particles were queer and totally different from the classical world. To address this issue Quantum Mechanics was developed in the 20th century by people like Max Planck, Albert Einstein, Niels Bohr, Werner Heisenberg, Erwin Schrodinger, Paul Dirac, Wolfgang Pauli, Richard Feynman, etc.  The basis of the modern quantum theory is the Uncertainty principle proposed by Heisenberg and it is built on the concepts of probability.





Probability in today's World

The twentieth century saw the mathematical theory of probability develop leaps and bounds. One of the basic problems of probability is finding a formal unambiguous definition of the mathematical origin. The theory is so realistic, obvious, and application-based that it was really tough to find a theoretical definition of probability. The classical definition was initially formed which was far from being sufficient and made way for the frequency definition. Finally, the frequency definition was replaced by the axiomatic definition given by the Russian mathematician Andrey Kolmogorov in 1933. The axiomatic definition is based on three axioms which are logical and accepted worldwide. It settled the long-standing disputes between mathematicians regarding the definition of probability. 

Probability and Statistics found a link and came together through the concept of hypothesis testing introduced by the Polish mathematician Jerzy Neyman and the British polymath R.A. Fisher. In modern times the concept of hypothesis testing is applied in various fields like biological and psychological experiments. It is used in the clinical trial of drugs and also in economics. Nowadays the idea of probability is used in concepts like the Markov process, Brownian motion, and other places where we have to deal with an aggregate of entities. Random fluctuations of stock markets are studied using probabilistic mathematical models to provide predictions for investors. So Mathematical finance has emerged as a new area of mathematics.








The modern era is an era of computer simulations, artificial intelligence, quantum computing, data science, etc. In almost all these areas the mathematical theory of probability plays a significant role. It is understandable that there is still a lot of room for development. Mathematicians all over the world work on stochastic models with the aim of improving the theory and increasing its applicability. We hope that a theory that developed from within the human society out of utmost necessity, will continue to develop and help humanity reach new heights in science and technology.




By

Prabir Rudra



Share:

Thursday, 4 April 2019

The Amazing Journey of E=mc2 : The Most Famous Equation of the World



More than a hundred years back a deceptively simple formula revealed a hidden unity buried deep in the fabric of the Universe. It connects energy with matter and the speed of light and was discovered by none other than the genius of Albert Einstein in 1905. When we think about E=mc2, we have this vision of an old white haired Einstein. But E=mc2 is not about an old Einstein. It is about a young, energetic and dynamic Einstein whose curiosity knew no bounds. 




The most famous equation of the World
The most famous equation of the World

Albert Einstein


                                                                          A young Albert Einstein


The half inch equation may seem to be so simple at the first look, but it is just a deception. Einstein in a stunning insight united the works of many who have come before him, scientists who fought and even died to form each sides of the equation. This is a story of those people who fought for the truth in spite of resistance and finally unveiled the secrets of nature. The story started long before Einstein with the discovery of E.


E is for Energy

London, England, early nineteenth century:

At that time scientists thought in terms of ‘Force’, ‘Pressure’, etc. They never had any idea about ‘Energy’ which could bring all these quantities under a single umbrella. Nobody knew that a lonely man’s quest for knowledge was going change the direction of science forever.

Michael Faraday was the son of a blacksmith who was lucky to work for a book binder as an apprentice. He never had the opportunity to acquire any elementary education. But he had an unending thirst for knowledge. He read all the books that reached him in the book binder’s shop. He wanted to escape from trade which he found vicious and selfish and wanted to become a servant of science, which he thought makes its pursuers amiable and liberal. He was determined to break free from his daily toil. 



Michael Faraday
19th century scientists were real celebrities of their time and getting a ticket to their lectures was very tough. Moreover at that time science was supposed to be a commodity of the so called gentleman, which Faraday was not. He got lucky when one of his customers got impressed with him and gave him a ticket to a lecture of the great chemist Sir Humphry Davy. Faraday never knew that this was going to change his life forever. 


Humphry Davy


                                                     Sir Humphry Davy



He was highly impressed with Davy’s lecture and became his ardent follower. His real opportunity came when Davy met with an accident while working in his laboratory, which severely damaged one of his eyes. In such a crisis, Davy appointed Faraday as one of his laboratory assistant. This opened the doors of knowledge to Faraday and he eagerly absorbed all that Davy deigned to impart. But who would have ever thought that in time the pupil would surpass the master.

Battery was newly invented at that time and as a result electricity was the order of the day. It was recorded by various scientists including Davy that a magnetic compass placed in the vicinity of a current carrying wire showed deflections.  How could electricity have any connection with magnetism, which were thought to be totally separate subjects at that time!!! Everybody was surprised and nobody could give any explanation to the observed phenomenon. Faraday speculated that perhaps some sort of electrical force is emanating outwards from the wire which was responsible for moving the magnet. This came as a shock to the scientific society nearly 300 years back because the prevailing concept at that time was that electricity flows through a wire and not sideways or out of it.

Electricity creating magnetism


Electricity creating magnetism






Lines of Forces
But Faraday was determined to reach the heart of the problem and unveil the truth. In a great leap of imagination he turned the problem in its head. Instead of an electrified wire moving a magnetic compass he wanted to know whether a static magnet could move a wire. This became the experiment of the century: The invention of the Electric motor. Although he did not understand at that time, he invented a new kind of physics. He had actually invented an over-arching principle. The chemicals in the battery had been transformed into electricity in the wire which would combine with a magnet to produce motion of the wire. Behind all these various forces there was a common ENERGY.




The set up of Electric Motor


The set up of Electric Motor

The achievements of the son of a blacksmith was opposed by many including his own master Davy. Davy was the elected president of the Royal society of London at that time. He accused Faraday of plagiarism (which was proved wrong)  and asked Faraday to put down his application seeking to be a member of the society. Faraday refused to do so and was soon elected a member of the Royal society on basis of his contributions to science. Davy died 5 years later, a victim of his many gaseous (specially laughing gas, N2O) inhalations. He was truly a great scientist of his time and had a few inventions to his name, but history will record his greatest invention as Michael Faraday.

With the passage of time Faraday’s world of invisible forces would lead to a whole new understanding of energy. He had actually shown that electricity and magnetism were not different entities (as it was thought to be at that time) but are forces that can be clubbed together into what is known as Electro-magnetism. He had started what Einstein would call the great revolution of unification.

Electromagnetic fields

Electromagnetic fields


M is for Mass

Paris, France, late eighteenth century:


King Louis XV was at the throne of France. But this was the era when the ancient absolute power of the monarchy was starting to be challenged by the common men. The French Revolution was lurking in the corner. It was the era of enlightenment which reflected that the development of humanity lies in science.

Antoine Lavoisier was an aristocratic wealthy young man who had a passion for science. He was not a scientist by profession. He was actually the head of tax enforcements in Paris. Lavoisier had an idea of building a great wall around the city and to tax every commodity that came in or went out through the wall. These political and economic activities enabled him to fund his scientific research. 

Antoine Lavoisier

Antoine Lavoisier



He was obsessed with matter and wanted to study and classify all its types. He had a great ambition to demonstrate that nature is a closed system: that in any transformation no amount of matter (mass) is ever gained or lost. He conducted an experiment where he heated water and produced its constituent hydrogen and oxygen gases. Then he combined the gases and got back water again. In the whole process he demonstrated that the total initial mass of the reactants was equal to the total final mass of all the products and successfully showed that no amount of matter was gained or lost during the transformation. 




Lavoisier's Experiment


Lavoisier's Experiment
To confirm this he conducted numerable other experiments which demanded accuracy. For this he had to commission very sensitive expensive apparatus which became possible only because of his position as a tax collector.  He became obsessed with accuracy. His experiments showed that forms of matter may change with transformations like solid, liquid or gas. Wood may become ash and smoke, metals may rust, solids may become liquid, but matter, the tiny atoms that make up all substances are never lost. This eventually laid the foundations of the law of conservation of mass.

On the other hand his methods of tax exactions was making the poor common people very angry. With the explosion of the French Revolution aristocrats like Lavoisier started losing their heads at the guillotine. After all, he was the despised tax collector who was always seen as an enemy of the common people. He was accused of tax fraud and adulteration of tobacco. Finally Lavoisier was denounced by a failed scientist turned radical journalist Jean-Paul Marat (whose scientific findings was once rejected by Lavoisier due to lack of proper scientific evidence) and was executed in front of the public at the guillotine on 8th May, 1794.


French Revolution
French Revolution
guillotine


Guillotine

Lavoisier was a great chemist of his time and is aptly known as the father of modern chemistry. His greatest accomplishment lies in changing science from a qualitative to a quantitative one. His findings with mass is central to the discovery of E= mc2.


C is for the speed of light


C stands for ‘Celeretas’ (latin word for swiftness). Since light travels with an incredible speed of 670 million miles per hour it was always considered as something which will be beyond the realm of human understanding. It was almost 100 years after Lavoisier that the world witnessed a young and energetic Einstein attending classes in the Zurich polytechnic, Switzerland. He was never an ideal student for his teachers. All he cared for in this world were Physics, Mathematics, Philosophy and his violin. All other things made absolutely no sense to him.

By that time everything that physically existed have been classified into two groups. One is matter, the building blocks of the universe and the other one is Energy, which excites matter. But nobody ever thought of any connection between the two entities. It was Einstein’s relentless pursuit of light that will bring about a revolution in science. With light he would re-invent the universe and find a hidden pathway that will unite energy and matter.

By the time Einstein arrived to the scene the speed of light have already been computed, but nobody actually knew what it was. One man whom we have already met was ready to make an educative guess on this. Michael Faraday became Professor Faraday after the death of Sir Humphry Davy. He became popular as a scientist and was known for his great experimentations. His concepts of invisible lines of forces that gave rise to electro-magnetism was still difficult for the people to digest. Now he was ready with another outrageous proposal. He proposed that light is actually one form of these vibrating lines of electro-magnetism. But as it happens everytime with science, nobody believed in him.

For 15 years Faraday struggled to convince the people that light was actually an electromagnetic wave but what he lacked was the knowledge of advanced mathematics that will back up his idea. Eventually a man by the name of James Clerk Maxwell came to his rescue. Maxwell not only believed in Faraday’s visions but also had the mathematical skills to prove Faraday right.



James Clerk Maxwell

James Clerk Maxwell
Maxwell in his calculations showed that the interlinking between electricity and magnetism can only happen at a particular speed, 670 million miles per hour. It was the speed of light. He had proved Faraday right. Electricity and magnetism woven together as electro-magnetism in its visible form was nothing but light itself.

Einstein with his never ending pursuit of light was slowly and unknowingly moving towards the link that would connect Energy with matter. He was studying rigorously the electro-magnetic theory of light that Maxwell had already proven. But one last mathematical ingredient that Einstein would need was the everyday process of squaring.




2 is for squared

Chateau Cirey, France, Early eighteenth century


For this we have go back more than a hundred years back, even before Lavoisier. At that time there was no idea how to quantify motion. All that existed was Galileo’s works and Isaac Newton’s Principia. Nobody ever thought that a crucial contribution to this subject will come from a very unusual source.

At that time King Louis XIV was at the throne of France. One of his courtyards had a daughter by the name of Emily Du Chatelet. She was a very intelligent young woman having an inclination towards science. In her tragic and short life she had a great impact on physics. She published many works of scientific research including a translation of Newton’s Principia in french which is still the standard text in France. She did all these at a time when science was considered to be a male commodity. She was ahead of any other woman of her time or even anyone upto hundred years later.

Emily Du Chatelet


                                                      Emily Du Chatelet





She was married to a general in the French army at the age nineteen and had three children. She ran a busy household and simultaneously pursued her passion for science. Emily took lessons from one of the greatest mathematicians of that time Pierre de Maupertuis, who was expert on Newton. She also had an affair with Voltaire, who was France’s greatest poet and a fierce critic of the king and the church. 



Voltaire was in prison twice and was exiled to England where he learned a lot about Newton. When he came back to France, he again got into problems with the king. At that time Emily hid him in her country home in Chateau. Far from Paris Emily and Voltaire turned her house into a centre of learning and culture along with the support of her husband (who mostly remained away busy with his duties at the army). 


Voltaire


 Voltaire




Newton stated that the the energy (force with which masses collide) is very simply mass of the object times its velocity. On the other hand a German scientist, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz had a different view to this. He believed that a moving object has a kind of inner spirit (which he called ‘vis viva’, latin word for living force). In his theory Leibniz was convinced that the energy of a moving body must be its mass times its velocity squared. 

But defying Newton and convincing the people against Newton’s theory in those days was almost an impossible task. This was where Emily came into the picture. She was highly convinced that Leibniz’s theory was correct, but the support for Newton was overwhelming. What she needed was proof in favour of Leibniz. 

Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz

Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz 

Finally she came across the experiments of a Dutch scientist, Willem’s Gravesande which showed that the observations indeed favour Leibniz. Gravesande’s experiment comprised of simply dropping lead balls into a pan of clay from a certain calculated height. 

His experiments showed that when we double the speed of the drop by increasing the height then the ball goes four times more deep into the clay rather than twice, thus giving evidence in favour of squaring the speed. Emily published the result in her famous book ‘Institutions De Physique’.  It is quite understandable that the work was not at all acceptable for the academy at that time.

All her life Emily tried to rise above the limitations placed on her gender. In the end it was an affair with a young soldier that brought about her demise. She conceived at an advanced age of forty-three which was considered to be dangerous in the 18th century. Finally she died six days after giving birth to her fourth child. 

Emily Du Chatelet’s conviction in the idea that the energy of an object is the function of the square of its velocity sent shockwaves through the academic society. It took hundred years after her death for the idea to be completely accepted, probably just in time for Einstein.


Einstein and his BIG idea 


By the time Einstein arrived in the scene it was all set for him to provide the final thrust towards framing the equation. All the quantities of the equation were already developed by the people who came before him. The timing was so perfect for him that it seemed to be God’s wish. Now all he had to do was to find a way to unify the physical quantities to produce the equation.

Einstein was not the so called good obedient student in the class as it was stated earlier. He had the least interest in attending classes which he said was boring. All he was interested in was light. As a result of this his professors in Zurich polytechnic did not like him at all and neither did they give him any recommendations for an academic position. He married his classmate Mileva Maric and had a child. 

Bern, Switzerland, 1905: 


After passing out of the Zurich Polytechnic in 1900, Einstein had to take a low paying job as a clerk in a patent office in Bern, Switzerland in order to run his house. After completing his daily work he had enough time at the office to think about science. He was relentlessly pursuing his question of light which he had now been thinking for ten years. Light became his obsession. His wife started complaining because his low wage made it difficult to run the house. His friends advised him to find a better job so that he could provide more comfort to his family. But Einstein had no effect of these on him. He wanted to know how God created the universe.

In a stunning insight he turned everything upside down. He changed the way how people thought about the universe. In Einstein’s universe one true constant was the speed of light and the other quantities can be bent so as to match the constant speed. In his amazing world neither space nor time were absolute quantities. This idea produced his paper on the Special Theory of Relativity. 

Some time earlier that same year he had already published his paper on Photoelectric effect which later won him the Nobel prize. He had also published a work on the structure of atom that same year (known as his miracle year). But he was not done yet. In one last great 1905 paper he would propose an even deeper unity. As his ten year journey with light was drawing to an end he noticed another strange connection between energy, mass and light.

He finds out that energy and mass are not at all separate entities but different forms of the same thing. As a result they can be converted into one another. Mass can be transformed into energy and vice versa. In fact all the matter that we see around us are huge reservoirs of nothing but energy. These masses are formed by the condensation of huge amounts of energy. So when these are annihilated, they give rise to huge amount of energy. With this clear idea in his mind Einstein calculated his way through to the most famous equation of the world, E=mc2. 

With four familiar notes in the scale of nature this patent clerk had composed a totally fresh melody- the culmination of his ten year journey into light. Irrespective of how far we reach in our scientific quest in the time to come, Einstein and his E=mc2 will keep whispering through the ages.


By Prabir Rudra






























Share:

Followers

Subscribe

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Powered by Blogger.